In conclusion…

Updated: Feb 14, 2020

This photography portfolio project has been a very enriching experience, both in terms of the skills I have learned along the way but also in helping me to get to know Edinburgh better and having a better appreciation of urban issues.



When I began this project, my intention was very clear: to identify and capture contrasts within the City that highlight on the tension between development and urbanisation in Edinburgh. I had in mind already a few scenes, such as the development of the St. James centre and its impact on neighbouring area and the contrast in architecture between old and new buildings. I discovered very quickly however that, as important as these were, they were not necessarily the central piece of the project. Pieces of the puzzle, certainly, but not enough to paint a clear picture.



50 pictures later, I have realised that actually, the tension between urbanisation and conservation was better expressed in chance shots than planned ones. Photography is of course about capturing a moment at a given time and a given place so no two photographs will be the same. Nevertheless, it was fascinating to notice that most of scenes that I was drawn to were the fleeting ones, i.e not just the contrast between the old and new buildings but instead instants that would vanish a few seconds later.




I think that there are two reasons for this:

· Fleeting moments that, in some ways, are great at telling the story. It is a snapshot of a moment that will not be repeated.

· Fleeting moments are more vivid, and therefore I think capture the questions of identity and tensions within a city even more powerfully.


Another benefit of those fleeting moments is that it has brought a lot of diversity into the photography portfolio, and brings to the fore a range of issues that I had not considered at the start of the project. For example:

· The impact architecture and buildings, old and new, have on the identity of the City.

· Mobility within the city, including for citizens with reduced mobility

· Developments encroaching on green spaces and vice-versa.

· Events in the city and tourism

· Community activism towards developments